Menus
Bagel-ish serves up the EXTRA-ORDINARY. The menu includes delicious, artisan, all natural sourdough bagels with savory breakfast and lunch sandwiches, including one-of-kind bacon, egg & cheese souffles with uncured no-nitrate bacon, local eggs & cheddar cheese; locally smoked no-nitrate lox with a choice of house blended fresh cream cheeses (including fresh whipped, fresh scallion & garlic, pickled jalapeño & garlic, organic strawberry & other savory & sweet flavors). We also have sourdough churros covered with melted butter and rolled in organic cinnamon & sugar. Our sourdough churros like a donut without the frying....crispy, chewy & sweet!
3 % Discount for Cash on All Orders
10% Discount for Hudson Valley Locals on Thursdays
Artisan Bagels
3% Discount on Cash Purchases-
Artisan Plain Bagel
Crispy on the outside, light & chewy on the inside. This sourdough bagel satisfies the senses as well as the gut.
$2.58
corn, gluten, wheat, dairy free option, plant based, sugar free, vegetarian, vegan
-
Whole Wheat Bagel
Surprisingly light blend of unbleached wheat and whole wheat flour, creating a crispy exterior (crust) and a crumb with a light, yet chewy texture with a distinctive depth of flavor. (This is quickly becoming the favorite of the owner, Beth)
$3
corn, gluten, wheat, plant based, vegetarian, vegan
-
Sesame Bagel
The sesame oil from the natural sesame seeds gives this sourdough bagel a unique crispy crust and soft and chewy crumb.
$3.12
mild, corn, gluten, sesame, wheat, dairy free option, plant based, sugar free, vegetarian, vegan
-
Everything Bagel
Bursting with flavor, this sourdough everything bagel is covered with our unique blend of whole sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried onions, dried garlic and salt.
$3.12
mild, corn, gluten, sesame, wheat, plant based, sugar free, vegetarian, vegan
-
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
The bagel has it all. Depth of flavor, high fiber, amazing texture with a crispy exterior (crust) and a light & chewy interior (crumb), and topped with our proprietary everything seasoning.
$3.25
corn, gluten, wheat, plant based, vegetarian, vegan
-
Rosemary & Extra Virgin Olive Oil Bagel
There's a little bit of Italian in all of us. Reminiscent of focaccia but with a chew and crisp, pairs perfectly with the Caprese - Ode to Frank -sandwich.
$3.33
corn, gluten, wheat, plant based, sugar free, vegetarian, vegan
-
Za'atar & Extra Virgin Olive Oil Bagel
A bagel with a Middle Eastern flair. The Za'atar is imported from Lebanon and made with pure wild thyme (za'atar), sumac, sesame and salt, and is the blended with extra virgin olive oil and drizzled over our sourdough bagels and baked to perfection. The bagel enhances any sandwich and pairs exceptionally well with the house made hummus & veggie sandwich.
$3.33
mild, corn, gluten, sesame, wheat, sugar free, vegetarian, vegan
-
Aleppo Pepper & Extra Virgin Olive Oil Bagel
This pepper is sourced from Turkey, but originates in Aleppo Syria. We blend it with extra virgin olive oil and top before baking, leaving a kick of a spice in the after notes of the bite. For those who like to turn the heat up, pair this bagel with the jalapeño & garlic cream cheese.
$3.33
spicy, plant based, sugar free, vegetarian, vegan
-
Cheddar & House Pickled Jalapeño Bagel
A meal in itself. This bagel has sensational flavor with our house pickled jalapeños and Wisconsin cheddar cheese.
$4.89
spicy, corn, dairy, gluten, wheat, vegetarian
-
Churro
Bravo! A twist on a Mexican favorite. We create a sourdough bagel stick (not fried) drench it in melted real butter, and roll it in organic cinnamon and organic sugar. We have nicknamed it our "healthy donut."
$4
corn, dairy, contains sugar, vegetarian, vegan
-
Egg Bagel (Specialty Item)
These Egg Bagels are the REAL DEAL made with real cracked eggs, with a bit of turmeric for color. They are reminiscent of challah bread. As with our other bagels, we use only unbleached unbromated flour and a real ingredients.... Most egg bagels are made with a fake egg wash and coloring. You will taste and feel the difference.
$3.33
egg, gluten, sesame, wheat, contains sugar, vegetarian
-
Egg Bagel with Everything Topping
Egg-y and Everything-y all in one. So yum!
$3.50
egg, gluten, sesame, wheat, contains sugar, vegetarian
Bagel Sandwiches
-
Lox of Love
All natural, no-nitrate lox* (from the Samaki Smokehouse), choice of cream cheese, house pickled or plain red onions, Kumato tomatoes, cucumber, & capers. (Balsamic/EVOQ optional). *This lox is exceptional, buttery, smokey and mild. We also sell this to go in 4, 8 and 16 ounce packages.
$18.54
corn, fish, gluten, sesame, wheat
-
Caprese - ODE to Frank
Fresh mozzarella, garlic & scallion cream cheese, fresh basil, kumato tomato, balsamic/EVOO dressing
$15.45
corn, dairy, gluten, wheat, vegetarian
-
Avocado & Veggie
Fresh sliced avocado, red onions (house pickled or plain), kumato tomato, cucumber, Aleppo pepper, (Balsamic/EVOO dressing - optional)
$15.45
corn, gluten, sesame, wheat, plant based, vegetarian, vegan
-
House Made Hummus & Veggie
Hummus, kumato tomatoes, avocado, cucumbers, red onion (pickled or fresh), balsamic/EVOO dressing (optional)
$15.45
corn, gluten, sesame, wheat, plant based, vegetarian, vegan
-
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Souffle
3 Hudson Valley eggs, cream, North Country Smokehouse no-nitrate smoked bacon (preserved with cellar and sweetened with real maple syrup), cheddar cheese (2 souffles per sandwich) Add tomato (1.50)
$12.88
corn, dairy, egg, gluten, sesame, shellfish
-
Turkey Bacon, Egg & Cheese Souffle
3 Hudson Valley eggs, cream, no-nitrate turkey smoked bacon, cheddar cheese (2 souffles per sandwich) add tomato (1.50)
$12.88
corn, dairy, gluten, sesame, wheat
-
Egg & Cheese Souffle
Cheese (2 souffles per sandwich) add tomato (2.00)
$10.78
corn, dairy, egg, gluten, sesame, wheat, vegetarian
-
Egg & Tomato Souffle
3 hudson valley eggs, tomato
$10.78
egg, gluten, sesame, wheat, vegetarian
-
Lox & Cream Cheese (of your choice)
A simple classic made with one of the one of kind all-natural no-nitrate, buttery, smokey, and subtle lox from Samaki Smokehouse.
$15.45
corn, dairy, fish, gluten, sesame, wheat
Drinks
-
Natural Waters, Sodas & Drinks in Cooler
$3.25
-
Poland Spring Water
$2
-
Organic Fair Trade Coffee
From Lacas Bros Coffee” (12oz)
$3
-
Decaf Organic Fair Trade Coffee
From Lacas Bros Coffee* (12oz)
$3
-
Rishi Organic Fresh Brewed Ice Tea
All organic: green tea, ginger root, lemongrass, lemon, essential lime oil (16oz)
$5
-
Rishi Botanical Hot Teas
Earl grey or peppermint (12oz)
$3.50
Bagel Spreads
Dairy Spreads
-
Pure Butter
$2
-
Whipped Cream Cheese
$2.50
-
Fresh Scallion CC
$3.50
-
Fresh Scallion & Garlic CC
$3.50
-
Fresh Jalapeno & Garlic CC
$3.50
-
Blueberry CC
$3.50
-
Strawberry CC
$3.50
Dairy Spreads To-Go
-
Pure Butter
2oz $1.50
4oz $3
-
Whipped Cream Cheese
8oz $9.25
2oz $2.75
4oz $4.75
-
Specialty Cream Cheese
2oz $3.50
8oz $6
4oz $11
Vegan Spreads & Extras
-
House Made Hummus
$5
-
Org Sunflower Seed Butter
$3.50
-
Org Blueberry Jelly
$2.50
-
Org Strawberry Jelly
$2.50
-
Avocado Side
$3
-
House Pickled Jalapeno Side
$2.50
-
Tomato Side
$2